The photograph of “a healthy man” to go with my Ragtag Daily Prompt conflate post.
I LOVE the caption. “Robust healthful manhood is the source of mental and physical power.” How differently the author portrays health womanhood, as shown in the conflate post. The book is Macfadden’s Encyclopedia of Physical Culture, in three volumes, 1911. Volume I is 500 pages. It is easy to read but it’s a different style from now. Here:
As a rule, if you will simply retain the idea that food should be swallowed at all times without effort, that is, that never, by any means, wash it down with water, milk, tea or any other liquid, that you should masticate it until it seems to disappear without swallowing, you can rest assured that you are masticating sufficiently. p. 97, volume I.
I plan to read the entire set. I think I will find lots of wonderful words for the Ragtag Daily Prompt (hey, I don’t think we’ve used masticate yet!) and material to write about.
Are there still interesting medical ideas out there? Oh, yes. LOTS. Only now they use the internet. I have subscribed to some of the series of videos, telling people how bad and wrong minded allopathic doctors are. Sigh. We do our best. The scam is that they let folks watch one a day for a week, or let them watch one, and then want you to buy the series. “Only $349.99!” Nice scam that is proliferating rapidly. I have now gotten emails saying “Health coaches should make as much or more than physicians and we can teach you how to market and target people and make that money.” Ugh and ick. Really?
I have patients in clinic who present by saying, “I don’t usually go to MD doctors, I go to a naturopath, but I am here because I need an antibiotic.”
I learn to respond gently. “Oh. If you need an antibiotic, maybe you have signs of infection? What are your symptoms?” I have to get past their dislike of allopathic medicine and find out what the symptoms are. Usually if I can diffuse them by getting the story, we can work together. Once in a while it doesn’t work: I have people come in and give me orders. “Do these labs.”
“Uh. Where did this list come from?”
The answer could be a video (by a naturopath, a biochemist, a biologist, whatever. I have watched some of these series. They start by saying that doctors are wrong/stupid/stubborn/misguided/etc.) or a “cash only” doctor or a magazine.
“Why are you coming to me?”
“I want medicare/my insurance to pay for it. I have done my research.”
“Well, medicare does not work that way. I have to list a symptom or diagnosis code for every lab ordered.”
I try to be patient. “Every lab has to have an attached appropriate diagnosis code or medicare will not cover it. There is a place in town where you can order your own, but it does not take medicare. You pay for it.”
“Just order it!”
“No. I am a medicare/insurance provider, which means I have a contract with them. It would be fraud and illegal to make up codes. Does your cash only provider use diagnosis codes? Can your bring their clinic note to me?”
One person replies, “My provider doesn’t take notes.” Oh, how nice. That provider does a very expensive panel of labs three times a year that the person is paying for out of pocket. “My provider checks EVERYTHING.” Um, and makes a boatload of money off you too, I think. That patient is very angry that I won’t take her orders and switches clinics. Oddly enough, this does not break my heart.
Some days I hate Dr. Google. There are lots of websites and people on line swearing that they can improve your health. There are scientific looking papers that swear something has been tested, but read the fine print: if the sample is 8 people, how does that stack up against the Women’s Health Initiative, where one arm of the study had 27,000 people? The evidence is weighted. We get multiple articles in medical school and subsequently about how to read a paper, how to weigh the evidence, how to recognize fraud or a poorly designed study.
I do not object to people looking on the internet and I have had people who came in and said, “Is it possible that I have THIS?” and who are correct. However, I see more fraud, always.
This would make life difficult for you. I wonder if it’s particular to America?……
The internet is a frightful place for a person with health anxiety.
Speaking of health worries, could I suggest that any use of “masticate” as a prompt word be accompanied by a warning of the possibility of hairy palms?
Heh. I will bet that this book addresses that topic somehow.
This robust healthy man seems to be missing a body part. Enjoyed your essay, as usual.
Maybe he’s been eating too many carrots and it’s fallen off?……
More to follow once I read the text
I believe side effects of overeating carrots can have devastating effects. Seeing in the dark……
Now I never heard about that side effect of carrots before.
No problem. I have nothing to lose.
Good to know……
the carrot thread….
or maybe karat thread.
Old medical texts used to be a collection interest of mine. My favorite was Christopher’s Surgery. It was a pre antibiotic treatise ons surgery of the extremities. The photos displayed some terribly infected or mangled hands and feet needing resection. Only surgical nurses, techs and surgeons could find deep interest in those pages. It was published in 1939, and was from a world that has thankfully sunken in the rear view. A lot of the interest in it was actually referred thankfulness that we had gotten better, and a prayer that we’d never have to slip back.
Seconding your prayer. I have acquired a pile of medical or quasimedical books, but the photographs and text of Macfadden’s are just wonderful. A huge change in 100 years and we’ll see another huge change in the next 100 years.
Imagine the early primitive ‘surgery’ conditions in war zones……
Ugh. Civil war saws.
It doesn’t bear thinking…….
Bears can do a lot of damage too. Even thinking bears.
We don’t have bears here but yes, I have heard that thinking (and non-thinking) bears can cause havoc. And don’t try and pet them. Like some try and do with our koalas….they can scratch
ooooo now I want to see your koala nonsense poetry
I am a cute koala
Posing for a pic
Held by somesuch visitor
Using selfie stick
Shit! he scratched me….
They don’t like being stroked miss…..
Got dripping blood….
Best I could do…..
heh, now I will be playing with koala rhymes all day